The Illusion of SEO — Why “Best Practices” Are Failing in Google’s AI Era

For decades, SEO followed a familiar script. Research keywords. Write meta titles. Optimize page speed. Build backlinks. Tick the boxes, follow the rules, and traffic would follow.

But in the aftermath of Google's AI-powered Search Generative Experience (SGE) rollout, the old playbook is quietly collapsing — and many haven’t noticed. Rankings are tanking. Click-throughs are disappearing. Yet the sites still look optimized.

So what happened?

The Rise of “Answer-First” Search

SGE doesn’t just reorder rankings. It removes the need for clicks altogether.

Where a search once delivered ten blue links, today’s AI-powered interface delivers synthesized answers right on the results page — drawing directly from websites but offering no incentive to visit them. The user gets what they need without ever reaching your site.

This means you could be the source, and still get zero traffic.

Fact check: In early field studies by SEO tool providers like Authoritas and BrightEdge, some industries saw click-through rates drop by 18–64% after SGE appeared. Sites that used to rank well still “appear,” but now only as citations beneath Google’s AI response — sometimes without attribution.

“Optimized” Doesn’t Mean Discoverable

The checklist approach to SEO worked when ranking meant visibility. That’s no longer true.

Many CMS-generated pages still follow best practices:

• Unique title tags

• Meta descriptions

• Keyword use

• Alt text

• Structured data

Yet they’re not surfacing — or worse, they’re being collapsed into thin or repetitive AI summaries.

Dynamic pages (common in CMS sites like Wix Studio, Webflow, or Shopify) are especially vulnerable. If category or location pages lack contextual depth, Google's AI interprets them as variations of the same thing and suppresses them. Entire directories vanish.

The “Best Practice” Blind Spot

SEO professionals and DIY site owners alike are still offering audits and roadmaps based on the old assumptions:

• “Fix your meta tags.”

• “Add schema.”

• “Blog more.”

These steps aren’t wrong — but they’re no longer enough.

Content needs to go deeper. Architecture needs to reflect purpose. Pages must demonstrate genuine topical authority, not just surface-level optimization. And technical SEO must now account for how AI selects sources, not just how Googlebot crawls.

A Changed Incentive Model

The most sobering truth?

Google no longer benefits from sending people to your site. If it can answer the question without a click — and serve more ads around it — that’s better for its business.

For site owners, that shift is existential.

Coming Up in Part 3:

Reclaiming Visibility — What It Now Takes to Rank in a Post-Click World

About the Author

Sarah A. Sherman is the founder of Illustrated Domain, a strategy-led digital agency recognized for helping brands thrive in a rapidly shifting search landscape. With 30+ years of experience spanning finance, film, and global nonprofit leadership, her work blends creative clarity with systems thinking. she now advises high-impact businesses navigate the intersection of AI search, SEO, and digital trust—building not just traffic, but reputational equity that endures.

Have questions or want to connect directly?

Book a call or email contact@illustrateddomain.com